Not many new blogs break into my multiple-daily-visit bookmarks, but over the past few weeks, Jeff Pearlman’s blog has become a must-read. Pearlman is an acclaimed author and longtime contributor to SPORTS ILLUSTRATED. He currently writes for SI.com.
(SI.com Writer Pearlman: SI Swimsuit Models Have “Alien-ish” Bodies)
Last Thursday Pearlman posted his reax to the recently-published Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue. And coming from a longtime SIer, his public view might surprise you. Here’s a taste:
So the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue arrived in the mail yesterday.
My primary reaction: Creepy.
More after the jump.
Before he launched into a critique of the swimsuit mag, Pearlman does remind us how much he loves working for Sports Illustrated. But he also is clearly not shy about making his objections felt about the once-yearly issue:
Now, I just find the issue strange. The average SI reader is probably a male in his mid-40s. The average SI swimsuit model is a girl … usually 19-, 20-, 21- or 22-years old. They almost always have breathtaking faces (and mirror-perfected come hither glances) … with the awkward bodies of 14-year-old boys. I once went on a Swimsuit shoot with Molly Sims, and was naively shocked to see her bathing suit stuffed with “cutlets” to make her relatively nonexistent breasts pop out. In person, Molly was cute and attractive, but not someone who would stop a guy in his tracks. Truth is, most of these girls (I use the term “girls” because they’re friggin’ half my age, and I’ve earned the right to be a grumpy old man) are more alien-ish than bombshell-ish.
Final thought on the topic: Picked up yesterday’s New York Post. The front cover had a picture of Bar Refaeli, the Swimsuit Issue cover girl, with a headline, AT LAST! A REAL STIMULUS. Now, let’s think about this. Literally, when a straight man sees an attractive woman, sometimes the blood will flush up his penis, causing what is commonly termed an erection. That’s the “Stimulus” in the Post headline. Thank God there was no real news going on …
I’d say 99% of SI readers feel exactly the same way. The other 1%? Women.
Yes, some of the models are hot, but most are glorified coat hangers that few people outside of old bats and gay men find attractive (see the people who run the fashion modeling industry).
There’s always been a disconnect between what guys want to see and the models SI presents them. (There are some notable exceptions, like Marisa Miller and Elle MacPherson.) Most males I know appreciate a generous female figure, but sadly, the majority of girls rolled out by SI are about as curvy as former New York Met Pete Harnisch’s first pitch of Spring Training.
In the post, Pearlman talked about seeing an SI model in person, and how unaffected he was. I had a similar experience. Two years ago I was in a L.A. restaurant and sat next to Brooklyn Decker at the bar for a couple hours. She looked to be about a 7. Attractive, but certainly not mind-blowing. She wouldn’t get a second glance at a hot Hollywood club.
Since the issue first came out, if you were a media member and you criticized the selection of girls in the swimsuit issue, you were labeled an out-of-touch hater. So it’s nice to see an SI employee come clean and tell the truth.
Especially when it comes to SI’s crass sexualization of the models when marketing the issue.
How does SI get away with it? When it couches that content against a venerable, iconic mainstream brand, clearly it can do whatever its wants - and readers and advertisers will look the other way.







8:56 pm on February 17th, 2009
I agree 100% with this guy. Lots of them have pretty faces, but the vast majority of them have no real curves whatsoever. There are always a few rare exceptions.
9:02 pm on February 17th, 2009
With all the porn you can find on the Internet these days, is the SI swimsuit issue really that relevant anymore?
9:03 pm on February 17th, 2009
Of course the SI models aren't going to look as good as in person. That's the whole fantasy about the swimsuit issue.
9:05 pm on February 17th, 2009
Anything with breasts, real or enhanced, is fine by me.
9:42 pm on February 17th, 2009
I'm not sure if I would say I don't find enjoyment out of the issue, the SbB girls are more fun to look at. That is WHEN THERE ARE NEW PHOTOS TO POST!!! Come on Brooks, you're killing us. The first shot of Wendy in a bikini and nothing to follow for three days?
10:25 pm on February 17th, 2009
if the image of a skinny woman conjures "14 year old boy" in your head….pretty ironic bringing the word "creepy" into the equation…
12:40 am on February 18th, 2009
As someone older than the average age, I would like to see some women in their 30s, or even 40s in the issue. Girls younger than my college-age daughter shouldn't be modeling anyway.
8:20 am on February 18th, 2009
No, Walt. I am 30; no 40 year-olds. 30s are o.k. but that's it. As for the article; he is absolutly right. Show me some curves anytime. I have been bitching about this for years. Victoria's Secret has the best models, they look like women for the most part.
@ X-Factor; not everyone wants to see full frontal, penetration, hard-core, girl on girl on girl on girl on guy on sheep action. Some of us have a little self control.
8:53 am on February 18th, 2009
What do you mean,? 5"8 with no hips, no butt, and no boobs, knobby knees, pointy elbows, and rosy cheeks????Sounds just like my 14 year old nephew
9:19 am on February 18th, 2009
hahahaha no x-stuff
9:48 am on February 18th, 2009
I agree 100 percent also. I would rather see more curves and less bones. I also dont think that the SI bikini mag is relevant anymore.
12:30 pm on February 18th, 2009
Curves=happy
1:07 pm on February 18th, 2009
Some aliens are pretty sexy.
12:51 am on February 19th, 2009
That chick on thats up at the top is kind of fug at least in the face.
Bar Rafiel is gorgeous tho.
I'm not really sure why Si has swimsuit issues (well besides the sales) but what kind of sport is posing in a bikini or half naked?
1:18 am on February 19th, 2009
Dan:
The best sport of all!
4:23 am on February 19th, 2009
Most of them look like 13 year old Trannies
3:30 pm on February 19th, 2009
i'd love to see pictures of all you guys that don't think these girls are attractive
something tells me you all have plenty of extra weight to give them
i'd take any one of 'em in a heartbeat
9:28 pm on February 19th, 2009
We know you would take any women from this magazine, but some of us prefer, at least on these blog comments, to at least fake like we are men and not desperate losers that would lose our good taste for the first anorexic eastern European that smiles at us from the pages of a magazine. Gimme a fully developed woman that ate a full meal last month and I would be in Heaven.