Manny News Trucks Media’s Persecution Of PEDrs

Three months ago I wrote that since Alex Rodriguez was found to have used steroids, the baseball Hall of Fame was eventually going to have to let in anyone who had the numbers to warrant induction. That included guys like Mark McGwire, who if not for the pall cast over his career by steroid-use suspicion, would already be in Cooperstown. Not to mention Roger Clemens and Barry Bonds, who may soon be unequivocally found to have used PEDs throughout their careers.

Alex Rodriguez Persecuted By Media While Historical Players Get a Pass

(OK, a little over-the-top)

Guys like Bud Selig, Bob Costas, dozens of holier-than-thou baseball writers, and plenty of other dinosaur media members though have continued to intimate with their words and deeds that confirmed (and suspected) steroid users should not be afforded the honor of entering the Hall.

But now with the news today of Manny Ramirez using PEDs, it’s getting to the point where if we don’t let steroid/PED users into Cooperstown, there won’t be anyone left to induct.

Manny, Clemens, ARod other PED users to Hall of Fame?

View Results

You won’t hear any of those hypocritical media members backtracking about the Hall of Fame today. Not yet. But I can guarantee you that the Ramirez revelation, regardless of his claims of innocence, will have an impact going forward on who is seriously considered for the Hall of Fame.

It has to, ‘else you might as well furlough HOF workers for the next decade or two.

The double-standard when judging guys like McGwire for the Hall is one of the most outrageous examples of hypocrisy ever wrought by the sports media. The HOF is littered by some of the most profound scoundrels to put on a uniform, yet those scumbags are shielded by revisionist baseball *traditionalists*.

Cooperstown beacon Ty Cobb is universally regarded as one of worst human beings to every succeed at sports. And that was without the benefit of the hyper-media coverage that we so much *enjoy* today. Can you imagine what we would know about him if he was playing today?

I’ve read several long accounts of Cobb’s life, and based on a mountain of circumstantial evidence, I have no hesitation in saying that Cobb cheated as a player and also bet on games - on both sides - during his playing and managing career. The guy truly was a wretch in every sense of the world.

Anyone who has studied him and doesn’t see that is blind.

Also, if steroids were around, do you think Cobb, who would punch his mother in the mouth to get an edge over his opponent, would’ve not used them? Please.

So to leave out a guy like McGwire, while protecting people like Cobb is nothing short of a disgrace. Especially considering that guys like Selig, Costas and others consider themselves to be baseball historians. (I know McGwire’s numbers pale next to Cobb’s, but they’re still easily good enough to get him into Cooperstown - especially considering his contribution to the renaissance of interest in the game.)

The news about Ramirez today I hope is finally a turning point when it comes to how we judge the game historically. It’s time to stop demonizing players over the use of PEDs. Yes, it’s abhorrent to the game, but it’s happened for decades - and will continue to happen.

Get over it.

10 comments

  1. GravatarBrian
    5:03 pm on May 7th, 2009

    Well said Brooks.  I am convinced that the only people that care about PEDs are talk radio blowhards.  The steroid era, while unfortunate,  is not something the average fan loses sleep over.

  2. GravatarKeith
    5:22 pm on May 7th, 2009

    Agreed Brooks. That's the problem with baseball right now. Too many media types put Cobb, Ruth and others on such a high pedistal, that they go on their high horse now when someone is caught cheating.

  3. GravatarBrad S
    7:10 pm on May 7th, 2009

    "Can you imagine what we would know about him if he was playing today?"

    Ty Cobb would've smothered his own career in the crib if he acted the way he did today. It's highly unlikely he would've gotten past AA ball today with attitudes that were considered to be expected behavior back then (especially the racial ones).

    Which is one big reason why we should be leery of getting into "presentism" when discussing whom to let into the HOF. Differing standards of morality between the eras, you know.

  4. GravatarBrad S
    7:17 pm on May 7th, 2009

    As far as folks like McGwire and Bonds being denied the HOF: It's extremely hard to make a case to keep out players who helped make Major League Baseball a global game, despite the PED usage. After all, McGwire, Bonds, et al, saved MLB from a date with irrelevance.

  5. GravatarBrooks
    1:25 am on May 8th, 2009

    My god, keeping Manny out of the HOF?

    Please, for the love of all that is holy, stop listening to Mike &  Mike!

    (POT ROAST!!!)

  6. GravatarJoe E. Gladstone
    1:42 am on May 8th, 2009

    it was Manny just being Manny

  7. GravatarAlex Rodriguez
    1:43 am on May 8th, 2009

    Thank you Manny

  8. GravatarKeeter
    2:57 am on May 8th, 2009

    give everyone steroids.  I want to see 1000 ft homeruns and pitchers clocking 125 on the radar

  9. GravatarFlying Tilapia
    2:27 pm on May 8th, 2009

    Hm.  I think the gates of Cooperstown will remain closed to these players, until a few classes of them are inducted prior to their outing as juicers.

  10. GravatarSbBGirl Whitney's #1 Fan
    7:11 pm on May 8th, 2009

    GIVEN: The Baseball Hall of Fame is supposed to be a repository of baseball history.

    GIVEN: Breaking baseball's records via steroids is part of the sport's history.

    GIVEN: Denying these people (McGwire, Bonds, Ramirez, Canseco, etc.) access to the Hall of Fame is like denying that they existed and that the Steroids Era is not happening.

    CONCLUSION: Let them all into the Hall of Fame, steroids or otherwise.. but tell their whole story. Tell the world that their performances and records were artificially-enhanced… and let future fans of the sport (if any) be the judge.

Leave a Reply