Family of Wrestler’s Wife Loses Lawsuit v. Hustler

When Nancy Benoit was murdered at the hands of her husband Chris last year, Hustler magazine decided to pay tribute to the late wrestler’s late wife - by publishing lingerie & semi-nude photos she had posed for in the early ’80s.

Nancy Benoit

Well, Nancy’s family didn’t take too kindly to Larry Flynt profiting from the painful publicity of their daughter’s death. So they sued the publication of perverts’ choice for putting out the photos in their March 2008 issue.  However, a judge has ruled that publishing photos of the late Mrs. Benoit in the buff may be tasteless, but it’s not illegal.

The ATLANTA JOURNAL CONSTITUTION reports that Judge Thomas Thrash has dismissed the lawsuit filed by Nancy’s mother, Maureen Toffoloni, that publishing the photos violated her dead daughter’s privacy.

Photographer Mark Samansky had taken the photos of Nancy in the summer of 1983. Toffoloni’s suit argued that Nancy “never gave permission for the photos to be used for a ‘pornographic’ magazine whose content includes ‘graphic and sexual photographs of nude women.’”

Nancy Benoit nude

However, the judge ruled that Flynt’s mag was in their First Amendment rights to put out the pics - and were even somehow doing it for the public good:

Thrash, however, sided with Hustler in citing the freedom of the press and calling Nancy Benoit’s death “a legitimate matter of public interest and concern”.

“The fact that the Court personally views publication of the photographs to be offensive and distasteful is not determinative,” Thrash wrote.

Despite this setback, Nancy’s family isn’t finished with legal matters just yet. They’re considering filing a wrongful-death suit against the WWE over Chris killing Nancy and their son Daniel.  Well, it worked for Fred Goldman.

12 comments

  1. Gravatarjerryshortbuss
    3:13 pm on October 10th, 2008

    Very sad about what happened to Nancy. And she was such a hottie, too.

  2. GravatarCanesFan77
    3:32 pm on October 10th, 2008

    those are some hot pictures

  3. GravatarBronx Bomber Bombed
    3:45 pm on October 10th, 2008

    Chris Benoit was one messed-up guy. How could you kill such a gorgeous woman like that? And kill their young kid? Such a waste.

  4. GravatarNick N.
    3:50 pm on October 10th, 2008

    At least Hustler didn't show her autopsy photos. That would have been too much.

  5. GravatarDan Anderson
    4:05 pm on October 10th, 2008

    What some magazines wouldn't do to sell a few extra issues. But this is Hustler we're talking about.

  6. GravatarWarren Maple Sapp
    4:59 pm on October 10th, 2008

    Nice eye shadow.

  7. GravatarDunder Mifflin Security Guard
    5:25 pm on October 10th, 2008

    Love that classic '80s hair - God rest her soul.

  8. GravatarWes Welker Wuvs You
    5:31 pm on October 10th, 2008

    I don't find the photos themselves offensive. I find the fact that some roid-raging wrestler would kill his wife & son offensive.

  9. Gravatarjason
    5:47 pm on October 10th, 2008

    What's even more sad about this tragedy is that Chris Benoit was well-liked and well-respected by the fans and his fellow wrestlers. He was the last person you would think of doing such a horrible thing.

  10. GravatarMinnyCooper
    6:26 pm on October 10th, 2008

    It sucked when Eddie Guerrero died. But when this Chris Benoit stuff went down, I stopped watching WWE for good.

  11. GravatarPhil
    8:40 pm on October 10th, 2008

    I hope Hustler's happy and made plenty of money from the photos. Scumbags.

  12. GravatarEathan
    10:33 am on October 11th, 2008

    Wow those are hot pics.. I'm not sure they should be published..but wow!

Leave a Reply