Deaf Buckeyes Fan Sues To Get Stadium Captions

This is hardly an earth-shattering thing to say but we’re in favor of equality for all sports fans. That’s not to say that, say, Missouri Tigers fans are equally valid people as, say, Kansas Jayhawks fans - that’d be ludicrous. Rather, we think that anyone with the money for a ticket should be able to attend a sporting event if they so choose. We’re populist like that.

Ohio State Buckeyes

(”Hey, I can’t hear what the PA is saying!”)

That means we’re all for things like wheelchair ramps and seating, elevators, and handicap-accessible bathrooms. We’re in favor of paratransit to and from games. We’d even throw our support behind something like gluten-free options at concession stands. But we’ve got to draw the line somewhere, and we think we’ve found it. A hearing-impaired Ohio State fan is suing the university to force them to provide closed captioning of sporting events on video and score boards. We’d yell at him about this but…well, you know.

Consider, for a moment, the modern college sports experience. High-definition video boards carry replays of every play. Statistics on everything from QB rating to player tackles are displayed on scoreboards. But the one thing that people are there to see, football teams running football plays on a football field, is still front and center for anyone with a functioning pair of eyes. However, according to OHIO.COM, that isn’t enough for at least one fan:

‘When I go to a game, I’m never able to follow the game,” said Vincent Sabino, 32, of Hilliard. ”It takes away from being a fan. It’s a game experience thing.”

The lawsuit was filed late last month in federal court in Columbus by the National Association of the Deaf in Silver Spring, Md. The suit says the university is violating the Americans With Disabilities Act by not providing captioning at all its venues, including Ohio Stadium, Schottenstein Center and St. John Arena.

You can’t follow a game without closed captioning? You follow a game with your eyes, bud, not your ears. Incredulous dismissal of Sabino’s claim by a snarky blogger aside, the Americans With Disabilities Act requires that venues make “reasonable” accommodations for fans. The aforementioned game and scoreboard is surely plenty reasonable for anyone whose motives are pure.

Hell, have you ever attended a college football game? Most of the time, the announcers and referees are drowned out by tens of thousands of raucous, drunken fans anyway. Even people whose ears work fine have a hard time hearing things at games. Hey wait…having a hard time hearing things? Maybe hearing fans have a case, too. How much money could we make, anyways? Vincent, call write us and let us know!

5 comments

  1. GravatarBobo
    5:08 am on July 20th, 2009

    I don’t know…this seems like kind of a jerkwad article. You are really saying he is screwed up in the head because he has a disability? Sometimes people with disablities go so they can experience things we “normal” people do. By your own admission you and I normally can’t hear announcers and referees in a large stadium…so what is the problem exactly?

    I’ve been to baseball games, football games and…get this..even major ampitheater CONCERTS that have a hearing impaired section with someone signing the words of songs, yet the, as you call them, aurally challenged folks can’t hear a damn thing.

    So its awesome that you are so big to go along with ramps and elevators and gluten free food, but its too bad you can’t support deaf fans, idotic or not, to help them get the whole experience.

    Maybe you should look around…many facilities have something similiar, albeit they aren’t large sections or groups of people, but they do exist.

  2. GravatarPete Gaines
    8:00 am on July 20th, 2009

    Yeah, Bobo. I think I laid it on too thick there. I still think his claim that he can’t “follow the game” without a PA announcer is dumb, but to call him stupid for it…like you said, kind of a jerkwad thing to say.

  3. GravatarSpinMax
    8:29 am on July 20th, 2009

    Doesn’t ‘closed’ captioning mean you can choose to see it or not? This is forcing everyone to see it. I know ppl who go to games that can’t hear the PA and they still had a great time. Everyone looks at the scoreboard for the down and distance anyway.

  4. Gravatarparkerz
    9:24 am on July 20th, 2009

    It is called Open Captioning.

  5. GravatarShane
    12:15 pm on July 20th, 2009

    Wait, this guy goes to Ohio State. He can’t read!

Leave a Reply