If there’s one thing that sports blogs have done very well over the past 5 years or so, it’s that they’ve shed some light on the deeds and misdeeds of athletes, coaches, and front office types. Beat writers and columnists have a harder time sweeping things under the rug to protect their chummy relationships and access, now that fans have a way to express their outrage and hold people accountable when they say or do dishonest things.
But perhaps not enough attention is given to the people who do keep their words and act in good faith. Being a man of your word doesn’t often make for compelling reading or righteous indignation. That’s why people freaked the heck out out when the White Sox traded lovable lout Jim Thome to the Dodgers. But they were wrong.
Fans and media alike saw the trade as an admission the White Sox were giving up on the season, that GM Ken Williams was waving the white flag. Williams refused comment for several days after the trade and people latched on that as a sign Williams was running scared from criticism. According to the CHICAGO TRIBUNE, though, there was a good reason behind the trade and subsequent silence:
Basically, how it came down was when I first traded for him from Philadelphia, I promised him that as long as he was in a White Sox uniform, I would aggressively try to go after a championship.
“Unfortunately, even with the additions that we’ve made this year — and I do think that we’re a better club than when we started the season — we have not played very well, as indicative of the [3-7] road trip from hell. So, at that time, I made the decision to at least explore [waiver trade] opportunities.
The man has always expressed to me that personal accolades are not as important as ultimately getting a [championship] ring, so … he made a decision [to waive his no-trade clause], and I told him … I would support him in anything he wanted to do and I let him go.
Despite the sputtering outrage from the South Side, Williams was correct. Even if the White Sox sneak into the playoffs, they’re not a serious championship contender and everyone knows it. Jim Thome is one of the nicest guys to ever play the game of baseball, and it’s a damn shame he hasn’t been able to win a World Series ring. Why not give him a chance to get one by sending him to the best team in the National League?
The White Sox have a good young core of players that will keep them competitive for years to come. In fact, one could even argue that those young players deserve a chance to try their hand at DH instead of Thome, to put the team in better position in future seasons. We’ve all seen what happens when a team ignores the need to rebuild until it’s too late (see: 2009 Boston Red Sox). White Sox fans should be praising Williams for keeping the best interests of both Thome and the organization in mind - and also for keeping the promise he made to Thome years ago.







4:41 pm on September 5th, 2009
Is your “guess” article a product of your imagination, or did you perform actual research on this?
If you actually lived in Chicago, and maybe even listened to some sports radio in the city, you would know that Thome being traded didn’t even cause a ripple in even the most casual of White Sox’s fans lives.
He’s old, he sucks in the clutch, and being a good guy, Williams traded him to put him in a position to possibly win a ring. No one is losing any sleep over Thome getting traded because of his ability. Honestly, did you get paid for that article?
5:02 pm on September 5th, 2009
Howie- You’re and idiot. I live in Chicago, and have been a Sox fan since I started watching/playing baseball at the age of 5. The day after Thome was traded, the topic was discussed on the Score for about 5 hours, seems like some sort of ripple.
He’s a first ballot hall of famer, and he represents the polar opposite of what most ball players today represent. Integrity, class, and the fortitude to put the team in front of the individual.
It’s a good thing you dont’ get paid for your comments, you’d be scrubbing urinals for beer money.
2:13 am on September 6th, 2009
My guess is that Howie is one of the first people in Back of the Yards to get internet access. We should celebrate that.
8:26 am on September 6th, 2009
The 2009 redsox were supposed to rebuildthis year? Really?ok.
8:50 am on September 6th, 2009
best team in the national league….i didnt know the cardinals got thome?
11:45 am on September 6th, 2009
Big Daddy Woz—yeah, good thing you’re not running even a fantasy league, because you’d be donating your money to me every year.
Nice guy, who cares, good family man, go home and play with your kids. Yes, I’m paraphrasing from a movie, but it fits. First ballot, that’s your opinion. Jim Rice wasn’t a first ballot, and Thome won’t be either.
While IT was discussed, ad naseum, as the Score has nothing better to do, because the Score is a SOX channel!! what else are they going to talk about?
They can’t fill their stadium, and all the Sox fans worry about is getting drunk and running on the field. And no, I’m not a Cubs fan asstard.
11:46 am on September 6th, 2009
Pete Gaines-anyone with an opinion can write on this site, I believe you’ve proven that. Try doing a bit more research than reading the Trib, or listening to the Score. But, that’s probably why you found this job on Craigslist or some other Web rag.
9:18 pm on September 6th, 2009
Hey Howie, Thome will finish his career with 200 more home runs than Rice. Again, first ballot hall of famer. And speaking of rags, can you come pick up your wife from my house? I’m done with her.